Over the past few years, coffee substitutes have seen a surge in interest as people search for more nutritious choices to their morning coffee. Two popular brands in this space are Ryze and MUDWTR. Both offer mushroom-based beverages designed to boost energy without the negative side effects often connected to caffeine.
Here, we'll take a closer look at these two brands to help you determine which could be the better option for your needs.
Formulation and Ingredients
MUDWTR's flagship product consists of a combination of natural components, including:
Chai tea blend
Cacao
Lion's mane fungus
Chaga mushroom
Cordyceps mushroom
Reishi mushroom
Turmeric
Cinnamon
Himalayan salt
Meanwhile, Ryze's mushroom coffee blend features:
Arabica coffee
Cordyceps fungus
Lion's mane mushroom
Reishi mushroom
Shiitake fungus
Turkey tail fungus
King trumpet fungus
MCT oil
Coconut milk powder
MUDWTR and Ryze focus on using organic ingredients and functional fungi. That said, they differ in some aspects. The MUDWTR formula has a wider range of ingredients, with the addition of herbs and cocoa. Ryze, meanwhile, includes actual coffee and MCT oil, which may appeal to those seeking a closer coffee substitute.
Caffeine Content
A key distinction between MUDWTR and Ryze is their caffeine levels.
The MUDWTR formula includes approximately 35 mg of caffeine per serving, which is roughly 14% of the caffeine present in an average cup of coffee.
Ryze, on the other hand, contains approximately 48 mg of caffeine per serving, which is slightly more than MUDWTR but still considerably less than regular coffee.
This disparity may be important for those who are trying to reduce their caffeine intake. MUDWTR might be the better choice for people aiming to substantially lower their caffeine use, while Ryze may be preferred by those looking for a middle ground between traditional coffee and a caffeine-free substitute.
Flavor and Taste
How these beverages taste is subjective, but certain flavors stand out for each.
MUDWTR is often described as earthy and mildly spiced, with undertones of chocolate from the cacao and chai tea elements from the herbal ingredients. Some users liken it to a not-too-sweet cocoa or a chai latte.
Ryze, including coffee beans, has a more traditional coffee flavor. That said, the inclusion of adaptogenic ingredients adds a distinctive element. Users often say it's less bitter and more balanced than standard coffee.
Which one you prefer will probably be influenced by if you want something completely different from coffee (MUDWTR) or a beverage reminiscent of regular joe (Ryze).
Health Benefits
These two products tout numerous nutritional advantages because of their inclusion of functional fungi.
Possible health perks are:
Improved focus and mental clarity
Sustained energy levels
Immune system support
Lower stress levels
Enhanced rest
Antioxidant properties
Keep in mind, though, that although adaptogenic fungi have a long history in holistic health practices, further scientific investigation is necessary to fully understand and verify their health benefits.
Cost Comparison
When it comes to price, these two products are pricier than standard coffee grounds.
As of the time of writing, a ryze vs mud wtr month's supply of MUDWTR's original blend sells for around $50, while a month's worth of Ryze costs approximately $36.
Both brands offer recurring delivery plans that make each serving more affordable. Additionally, they frequently offer discounts that reduce the overall cost.
Regarding overall value, it's important to factor in more than just the cost. Should these coffee substitutes enable you to stop your regular coffee consumption, the long-term savings could be significant.
Convenience
The coffee alternatives are created with easy to prepare.
To make MUDWTR, you just mix a spoonful of the mix to hot water and stir. Many users prefer to include dairy or non-dairy milk and a bit of honey to make it more palatable.
Ryze is brewed in a similar manner. You mix one scoop of the formula with warm water and stir. Some users find that Ryze dissolves better than MUDWTR, which may have a slight texture.
MUDWTR and Ryze provide additional items like blenders to ensure smooth preparation, which comes in handy when making lattes or other specialty drinks.
Customer Reviews and Satisfaction
Both MUDWTR and Ryze have accumulated many loyal customers and mostly favorable feedback.
A lot of people who try MUDWTR say noticing enhanced mental clarity and stamina without the negative side effects linked to standard joe. A few customers point out that it needed a few days to appreciate the unique flavor, but the majority end up enjoying it as they drink it more.
Ryze customers often praise the product's ability to provide steady energy without the negative effects of coffee. Many appreciate the more familiar coffee-like taste, especially those transitioning away from regular coffee consumption.
Both products face some negative feedback, with a few customers noting gastrointestinal problems or no significant benefits. That said, such criticisms seems to be less common.
Final Thoughts
Deciding on MUDWTR and Ryze ultimately comes down to your personal preferences and health goals.
For those seeking a novel alternative with a one-of-a-kind flavor and minimal caffeine, MUDWTR could be ideal.
On the other hand, if you prefer a beverage reminiscent of regular joe with a stronger caffeine kick and easier mixing, Ryze could be the better option.
Both products offer {potential health